If you’ve followed In Good Cents for a while, you’re probably well aware of the fact that I love rules. I’m far from perfect, so, of course, I don’t judge those to break the rules. I do, however, strongly believe that you should know and understand the rules, so you can make an informed decision.
It’s possible I let my sarcastic side shine yesterday when sharing some of the new fine print on coupons, but I skipped over the best coupon I found. I mainly skipped it, because it gives me the perfect opportunity to answer a question many of you have asked me.
Is buying coupons illegal? Is selling coupons illegal?
While long ago, I would have told you it’s a “no, no”, a recent conversation with my husband made me realize that I don’t really feel that way.
“Reproduction, alteration, transfer, or sale of this coupon or it’s contents is prohibited and is a criminal offense.” – Kraft
Kraft sold me this coupon. Well, not exactly, but essentially.
Actually, Kraft placed this coupon in the 8/19/12 Smart Source insert, which in my area is only available in the the Indianapolis Star. Everyone in my area had to pay at least $0.50 to get it without stealing a newspaper from the stands.
If I’m honest, I can get news and store ads online for free, so the only reason I buy the Indianapolis Star is to get the coupons. Did the Indianapolis Star commit a criminal offense by selling it to me or is the Smart Source insert considered “FREE with purchase”?
There is no law against buying or selling coupons.
“When a person buys coupons, they may be inadvertently purchasing stolen property or counterfeit coupons. Even if there is not a direct criminal penalty involved, both coupon buyers and sellers open the door to potential litigation when they buy or sell coupons because they are in violation of the “nontransferability” clause printed on all coupons distributed within the United States. The transfer makes a coupon void.“
A Coupon is a Contract
When a consumer uses a coupon, they are agreeing to the terms of the coupon, just like they’ve signed a contract on the dotted line. The same goes for retailers when they accept a coupon. It’s like one big handshake between the manufacturer, customer, and retailer.
While the police won’t come knocking at your door, the manufacturer who released the coupon could technically take legal action against you for violating your contract. Plus, after you buy a coupon, per the contract, the coupon becomes void and therefore has no value.
So are all the coupons in the Smart Source insert void, if I can’t get them without buying them?
Void if Transferred or Exchanged
While I may have gone off on a tangent about zip code couponing, I wouldn’t think twice about passing on a coupon for diapers to a new mother or donating coupons to the military, but apparently I’m just handing out useless coupons.
I love Kraft products, so if I thought my neighbor would love them too, why doesn’t Kraft want me to give her a Kraft coupon to encourage her to give it a try? Or if she’s struggling, give her a few coupons to help her out financially?
I can understand why companies wouldn’t want people buying or selling their coupons in bulk, but what do they have against sharing or swapping coupons with a friend?
Where to Get Void Coupons
The Coupon Information Center goes on to say:
Individuals selling or auctioning coupons often know that such sales and auctions are in violation of the terms and conditions of the coupons. As such, they may include an invalid disclaimer, such as, “I’m selling my time to clip the coupons, not the coupons themselves.” Such disclaimers are invalid and do not provide any legal protection to either party. Such obviously invalid disclaimers merely serve to prove that the seller/auctioneer knows that their illicit coupon sales are inappropriate, wrong, and subject to civil and/or criminal penalties, depending on the situation.
If selling your time to clip coupons is cutting hairs, then there are a lot more offenders out there. And, didn’t they just contradict themselves in regards to criminal penalties?
Wanted: For Transferring or Selling Coupons
- Newspapers Nationwide: They won’t give you the coupons inserts for free. You have to buy them.
- Magazines: Once again, they won’t give you the coupons in the magazine. You have to buy them.
- Coupons.com Savings Club: They aren’t selling coupons, they are selling a membership to print coupons.
- Overseas Coupon Program: OPC is collecting donated coupons and transferring them to overseas military.
- Coupons for the Community: Volunteers here collect donated coupons and transfer them to local food pantries.
- Coupon Clipping Services: Of course, we can’t forget the most obvious. Those who sell full inserts and individual coupons to couponers.
- Me and My 5-Year Old: My youngest daughter has been saving up to buy her sister a special birthday present and since she’s was little short, I gave her a coupon today to help her out.
- My 7 Year Old: Coupons do say that you can’t use them if you’re under 18, even though you can’t enter into a legal contract at the age of 7, so maybe Ady will get off easy. However, she did clip all of my cat coupons and donate them to the local pet shelter.
Should we get a mob together and gather our pitchforks to go after these offenders who are publicly violating the terms of the coupons and encouraging others to participate as well?
And Since We’re Not Cutting Hairs
I have a few more to add to The Wanted list.
- Manufacturers: Who transferred the coupons to the inserts, magazines, and coupon websites, then essentially to us.
- Newspaper and Mail Delivery People: Better handcuff the paper boy when he delivers your paper Sunday, because he just transferred coupons to you!
- Customers: If you’ve used a coupon, therefore transferred it to the store, you’d better handcuff yourself too!
- Anyone Who’s Ever Touched a Coupon: Unless, of course, you are the only person to ever touch the coupon and are keeping it in your own protective custody so you don’t void the terms.
I realize this is ridiculous, but striking fear into your customers with threats of criminal penalties, is even more ridiculous. Especially when, unless you’re sticking small GPS trackers into your coupons, there’s no possible way to police this.
Do I Buy Coupons (Seriously)?
With all the free coupons available and the number of fraudulent coupons sold on the internet, I’ll admit that I don’t buy coupons. That doesn’t mean I’m against it. In fact, I recommend buying coupons in certain circumstances, but only from a reputable coupon clipping service.
Have you committed a “criminal act” that you’re proud of?
More Ways to Save:
- Couponing Gets More Complicated with New Fine Print on Coupons
- Donate Expire Coupons
- Coupon Clipping Services: Where to buy coupons
- What is Coupon Fraud?
- Extreme Couponing vs. Realistic Couponing
- Couponing for Dummies
- Ethical Couponing: How to Coupon with Grace